When you think of Jim n Nick’s Bar-B-Q, the first things that come to mind are slow-smoked meats, scratch-made sides, and famous cheese biscuits. But what many first-time visitors don’t realize is that Jim n Nick’s also offers a delicious desserts menu that rivals its barbecue lineup.
From their legendary banana pudding to seasonal cobblers and pecan pie, Jim n Nick’s desserts are the perfect sweet finish to a hearty Southern meal. Whether you’re dining in, ordering takeout, or planning catering, dessert is something you don’t want to skip.
In this detailed guide, we’ll explore the Jim n Nick’s desserts menu, prices, nutrition info, seasonal offerings, and tips to get the most value from your sweet tooth cravings.

Why Jim n Nick’s Desserts Stand Out
Jim n Nick’s dessert menu isn’t an afterthought—it’s a carefully crafted lineup of Southern classics that match the quality of their barbecue. Here’s why it’s special:
- Authentic Southern flavors – Recipes rooted in tradition, like pecan pie and cobbler.
- Scratch-made desserts – Prepared fresh in-house.
- Perfect portions – Generous servings, ideal for sharing.
- Affordable pricing – Usually between $4.99 and $6.99 per dessert.
- Seasonal specials – Rotating cobblers and holiday pies keep things exciting.
Jim n Nick’s Desserts Menu with Prices
Here’s a typical overview of the dessert menu (prices may vary by location):
| Dessert | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Banana Pudding | $4.99 | ~450 |
| Pecan Pie Slice | $5.99 | ~600 |
| Chocolate Cake | $5.99 | ~580 |
| Seasonal Cobbler (Peach, Blackberry, Apple) | $5.99 | ~520 |
| Whole Pecan Pie (for catering/holidays) | $19.99 | ~3,600 |
| Whole Cobbler (for catering) | $24.99 | ~4,000 |
Signature Desserts at Jim n Nick’s
Banana Pudding
- A creamy Southern staple made with layers of pudding, whipped topping, and vanilla wafers.
- Calories: ~450 per serving.
- Best for: Anyone who wants a light but rich finish.
Pecan Pie
- Sweet and nutty, served in a buttery crust.
- Calories: ~600 per slice.
- Best for: Fans of traditional Southern pies.
Chocolate Cake
- Rich, moist cake topped with chocolate frosting.
- Calories: ~580 per slice.
- Best for: Chocolate lovers craving indulgence.
Seasonal Cobbler
- Rotating flavors: peach, apple, blackberry, or mixed berry.
- Served warm with a flaky crust.
- Calories: ~520 per serving.
- Best for: Comfort dessert lovers who like variety.
Dessert Sizes & Catering Options
Jim n Nick’s doesn’t just serve desserts by the slice or cup—they also offer whole desserts for catering and holidays.
| Dessert Option | Size | Serves | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Banana Pudding Tray | ½ pan | 12–15 servings | $24.99 |
| Whole Cobbler | Large pan | 12–14 servings | $24.99 |
| Whole Pecan Pie | 8 slices | $19.99 | |
| Whole Chocolate Cake | 10–12 slices | $29.99 |
Nutrition & Allergen Information
While indulgent, it’s helpful to know what’s in Jim n Nick’s desserts.
- Gluten: Present in pies, cobblers, and cakes.
- Dairy: Banana pudding, cobblers, and cakes contain dairy.
- Nuts: Pecan pie contains tree nuts.
- Eggs: Present in cakes and puddings.
If you have dietary restrictions, always ask staff for the allergen menu before ordering.
Jim n Nick’s Desserts vs Competitors
| Restaurant | Signature Dessert | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim n Nick’s | Banana Pudding | $4.99 | ~450 |
| Mission BBQ | Banana Pudding | $3.99 | ~430 |
| Dickey’s BBQ Pit | Blondie Brownie | $3.49 | ~400 |
| Famous Dave’s | Bread Pudding | $6.49 | ~520 |
| Sonny’s BBQ | Banana Pudding | $4.79 | ~440 |
Jim n Nick’s offers larger portions and more catering options compared to competitors.
Best Dessert & Drink Pairings
Pairing desserts with drinks enhances the flavor experience.
| Dessert | Best Drink Pairing |
|---|---|
| Banana Pudding | Sweet Tea or Coffee |
| Pecan Pie | Bourbon or Black Coffee |
| Chocolate Cake | Cold Milk or Latte |
| Peach Cobbler | Sweet Tea or Lemonade |
Seasonal & Holiday Dessert Specials
Jim n Nick’s often rolls out holiday desserts:
- Pumpkin Pie (Thanksgiving).
- Holiday Pecan Pie Packs.
- Specialty Fruit Cobblers during summer months.
- Chocolate Peppermint Cake (Christmas, select locations).
Tips for Enjoying Desserts at Jim n Nick’s
- Share a dessert – Portions are generous, perfect for two.
- Order catering-sized trays – Great for office lunches or family dinners.
- Pair with coffee or tea – Enhances sweetness without being overwhelming.
- Save room – Consider ordering lighter sides at dinner to leave space for dessert.
- Check seasonal menu – New flavors rotate often.
FAQ
1. What desserts does Jim n Nick’s serve?
Banana pudding, pecan pie, chocolate cake, and seasonal cobblers.
2. How much is Jim n Nick’s banana pudding?
About $4.99 per serving, or $24.99 for a catering tray.
3. Does Jim n Nick’s offer whole pies or cobblers?
Yes, whole pecan pies and cobblers are available for catering.
4. What is the most popular dessert at Jim n Nick’s?
Banana pudding is the customer favorite.
5. Are Jim n Nick’s desserts made fresh?
Yes, all desserts are scratch-made in-house.
6. What seasonal desserts are available?
Rotating cobblers (peach, apple, blackberry) and holiday pies.
7. Do Jim n Nick’s desserts contain gluten?
Yes, most desserts contain wheat flour.
8. Is pecan pie available year-round?
Yes, but whole pies are especially promoted during the holidays.
9. Can I order desserts for catering?
Yes, trays, whole pies, and cobblers are available.
10. Do all Jim n Nick’s locations serve the same desserts?
Core desserts are consistent, but seasonal offerings vary.
11. How many calories are in banana pudding?
About 450 calories per serving.
12. How many people does a catering cobbler serve?
A whole cobbler serves about 12–14 people.
13. Can I add dessert to online or app orders?
Yes, desserts can be added when ordering online or through delivery apps.
14. What’s the price of a whole pecan pie?
Around $19.99, serving 8 slices.
15. Can I buy desserts without ordering a meal?
Yes, desserts can be ordered separately for dine-in, pickup, or delivery.
16. Do desserts come with family meals?
Not typically, but they can be added as extras.
17. What drinks go best with Jim n Nick’s desserts?
Sweet tea, coffee, or milk pair well with most desserts.
Final Thoughts
The Jim n Nick’s desserts menu is a sweet reflection of the brand’s Southern roots. With banana pudding, pecan pie, chocolate cake, and seasonal cobblers, there’s something to satisfy every sweet tooth. Whether you’re dining in, grabbing takeout, or catering a family feast, dessert is the perfect way to round off your barbecue experience.
If you’re visiting Jim n Nick’s, don’t just stop at the pulled pork and ribs—make room for dessert. Whether it’s a cup of banana pudding or a whole cobbler for the family, their desserts are worth every bite.














