Jim N Nick’s By the Slice Price, Calories & Nutrition’s 2026

If you love classic Southern desserts, then Jim N Nick’s Community Bar-B-Q has something that will surely satisfy your sweet tooth — Pie Slices. Whether you’re craving a rich chocolate cream pie, a buttery pecan pie, or a fruity apple pie, Jim N Nick’s has you covered with slices of these iconic pies, making it easy to enjoy a taste of Southern comfort in a manageable portion.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive into everything you need to know about Jim N Nick’s By the Slice, including:

Calories and nutritional breakdowns
Ingredients and allergen details
How their pies stack up against competitors
Healthier tips for enjoying pie
And 15+ customer FAQ answers to make your decision easier

View Full: Jim N Nick’s Menu Prices

Jim N Nick’s By the Slice Price

Menu Item	Price	Calories
Pie Slice (Choice)	$4.99	300–500 per slice*

Calories may vary by pie type, portion size, and extra toppings (whipped cream, ice cream).

What Makes Jim N Nick’s Pie Slices So Special?

Pie Slices at Jim N Nick’s are more than just your average dessert — they are a Southern tradition served in a portion that’s perfect for one. Whether you’re finishing up a hearty BBQ meal or just need something to satisfy your sweet cravings, these slices are always the right choice.

Why they’re worth it:

Generous portions of pie, served fresh and with a flaky crust
Classic Southern pies made with fresh, high-quality ingredients
House-made fillings that are rich in flavor, never too sweet, and always satisfying
A comfortable, manageable portion size for those who want a taste of dessert without overindulging

Each slice is a little piece of Southern heaven, bringing the comfort of homemade pies to your table.

Jim N Nick’s Pie Slice Flavors

At Jim N Nick’s, there’s no shortage of sweet options. Their pie slices come in a variety of iconic Southern flavors that offer something for everyone:

Pie Flavor	Main Ingredients	Tasting Notes
Pecan Pie	Pecans, corn syrup, eggs, butter	Nutty, caramelized sweetness
Sweet Potato Pie	Sweet potatoes, brown sugar, cinnamon	Earthy, spicy, smooth texture
Chocolate Cream Pie	Chocolate pudding, whipped cream	Rich, creamy, chocolatey
Apple Pie	Apples, cinnamon, butter, sugar	Tart, warm, comforting
Peach Pie	Fresh peaches, sugar, butter	Juicy, fruity, lightly sweet
Lemon Meringue Pie	Lemon filling, meringue topping	Tangy, sweet, light and airy

Tip: Pies are seasonally rotated, so keep an eye out for limited-time flavors.

Ingredients in Jim N Nick’s Pie Slices

While Jim N Nick’s doesn’t disclose their exact pie recipes, we can estimate the key ingredients based on the flavors:

Ingredient	Purpose
Flour	Base for the crust
Butter or Shortening	Creates a tender, flaky crust
Sugar	Sweetens the filling
Corn Syrup (in pecan pie)	Adds smooth sweetness and binds the filling
Eggs	Sets the filling
Fruits (Apple, Peach, etc.)	Forms the pie base
Nuts (Pecan, etc.)	Adds texture and flavor
Chocolate or Cocoa	For chocolate pies
Whipped Cream	Light topping for chocolate pies

Note: Ask the staff for specific details on ingredients if you have dietary restrictions.

Jim N Nick’s Pie Slices: Nutrition Facts

The calorie count for pie slices varies depending on the flavor and portion size. Here’s an estimated breakdown for a standard slice (1/8th) of each type:

Nutrient	Pecan Pie (1 slice)	Sweet Potato Pie (1 slice)	Chocolate Cream Pie (1 slice)
Calories	400–500	250–350	350–450
Total Fat	20–30g	12–20g	18–28g
Saturated Fat	5–8g	3–5g	8–12g
Cholesterol	40–70mg	20–40mg	30–60mg
Sodium	150–300mg	150–250mg	200–300mg
Total Carbs	50–65g	35–45g	40–55g
Dietary Fiber	3–4g	2–3g	1–3g
Sugars	35–45g	25–35g	30–40g
Protein	5–7g	3–5g	4–6g

Tip: The calories will vary based on toppings like whipped cream or ice cream.

Allergen Information: What You Should Know

Jim N Nick’s pie slices are made using traditional ingredients that contain common allergens. Here’s what you should be aware of:

Allergen	Presence
Milk/Dairy	Yes (in crust, whipped cream, and fillings)
Eggs	Yes (in pie filling)
Wheat/Gluten	Yes (in crust)
Soy	Possible (in whipped cream or filling)
Peanuts/Tree Nuts	Yes (pecan pie)
Fish/Shellfish	Not used
Sesame	Cross-contact possible

Tip: Always inform the restaurant of any allergies to ensure safe preparation.

Healthier Tips for Enjoying Pie Slices

While pie slices are a treat, there are ways to enjoy them while being mindful of your health goals:

Share a slice to reduce calorie intake
Opt for fresh fruit sides to balance the sweetness of the pie
Request no whipped cream or opt for light whipped topping
Pair with a lighter entrée like grilled chicken or a side salad

Jim N Nick’s Pie Slices vs Other BBQ Chains

Brand	Calories per Slice	Flavor Profile	Crust Texture
Jim N Nick’s	300–500	Rich, balanced, homemade	Flaky, buttery
Famous Dave’s	400–600	Creamy, sweet, decadent	Soft, dense
Cracker Barrel	350–500	Fruity, tangy	Soft, tender
Sweet Magnolia’s	450–550	Chocolatey, rich	Dense, creamy

Jim N Nick’s stands out with its flaky, buttery crust and rich, balanced fillings, offering the perfect mix of sweetness and texture.

Jim N Nick’s Pie Slices FAQ – 15+ Common Questions Answered

1. How many calories are in a slice of Jim N Nick’s pie?

A slice generally contains 300–500 calories, depending on the pie type.

2. Are the pies vegetarian?

Yes, the pies are vegetarian-friendly, though they are not vegan due to dairy and eggs.

3. What pies are available by the slice?

Typically, Pecan Pie, Sweet Potato Pie, and Chocolate Cream Pie are available by the slice.

4. Do you offer gluten-free pies?

Currently, gluten-free pies are not offered, but you can inquire about modifications.

5. Can I order a whole pie instead of a slice?

Yes, whole pies are available for purchase. You can order them ahead of time.

6. What types of pie do you offer seasonally?

Seasonal pies vary, but you may see apple pie, strawberry pie, or pumpkin pie.

7. Is there a sugar-free option?

Currently, there are no sugar-free pies available, but sugar-free whipped cream may be an option.

8. Can I get pie without whipped cream?

Yes, you can ask for no whipped cream or substitute it with a lighter topping.

9. How much do whole pies cost?

Whole pies typically cost around $17.99.

10. Are the pies served warm or cold?

Pies are usually served at room temperature, but you can request them warmed up.

11. Can I freeze pie slices for later?

Yes, pie slices freeze well, but it’s best to consume them within 3 months.

12. Are there any nuts in the pies?

Yes, pecan pie contains nuts, and other pies may contain tree nuts depending on the recipe.

13. Is the chocolate cream pie dairy-free?

No, the chocolate cream pie contains dairy in the pudding and whipped cream.

14. How long do pies stay fresh?

Pies are best eaten within 2–3 days, but they can be kept for up to 5 days in the fridge.

15. Can I order pie for delivery?

Yes, you can order pie slices through third-party delivery services like DoorDash or directly from the restaurant.

Final Summary Table

Feature	Details
Price	$4.99 per slice
Calories	300–500 per slice
Vegetarian	Yes
Vegan	No
Gluten-Free	Not available
Contains Nuts	Yes (in pecan pie)
Best Pairings	BBQ, coffee, ice cream
Flavor Profile	Rich, sweet, nutty, fruity
Customizable?	Yes (no whipped cream, different pies)

Final Thoughts

Jim N Nick’s Pie Slices are a must-try if you’re looking to end your Southern BBQ meal on a sweet note. Whether you’re a fan of pecan pie’s nutty crunch, the richness of chocolate cream pie, or the fruity, comforting sweetness of apple pie, these slices deliver classic Southern comfort in every bite.

While indulgent, Jim N Nick’s pies are crafted with real ingredients, and the portion sizes are perfect for those who want a satisfying treat without overindulging. So go ahead, enjoy a slice — it’s Southern hospitality at its best.