Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies Price, Calories & Nutrition’s
When it comes to Southern comfort food, few things are as iconic as a freshly baked pie. At Jim N Nick’s Community Bar-B-Q, they offer a selection of whole pies that are the perfect ending to a hearty BBQ meal. Whether you’re craving a classic pecan pie, a rich sweet potato pie, or a decadent chocolate cream pie, Jim N Nick’s brings those comforting flavors right to your table.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive into Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies, offering detailed insights into:
Calories may vary by pie type and portion size. The whole pie serves 8–10 people.
What Makes Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies Stand Out?
Whole Pies at Jim N Nick’s are more than just a dessert; they’re an experience. Whether you choose a sweet, fruity pie or a rich, creamy treat, each one is made with quality ingredients and a touch of Southern flair.
Why these pies stand out:
Made fresh daily — no preservatives or artificial ingredients
Flaky, buttery crusts that melt in your mouth
Generous filling made with real fruit, chocolate, or nuts
Great for family gatherings, BBQ parties, or a sweet treat after dinner
Each pie is designed to bring that home-cooked feel, but with the convenience of ordering from a restaurant you trust.
Jim N Nick’s Whole Pie Flavor Options
Jim N Nick’s offers a variety of classic pie flavors, each with its own unique filling and texture. Here’s a look at their popular options:
Tip: Be sure to ask about seasonal pies or limited-time offerings, which may feature seasonal fruit or flavors.
Ingredients in Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies
While the exact recipes are proprietary, here’s a general breakdown of the key ingredients that make these pies so delicious:
Ingredient
Purpose
Flour
For the crust
Butter or Shortening
For the buttery, flaky texture
Sugar
Sweetens the filling
Corn Syrup (for pecan pie)
Adds sweetness and binds the filling
Nuts (Pecan, etc.)
Adds texture and flavor
Eggs
Thickens and binds the filling
Fruits (Peach, Apple, etc.)
The base for fruity pies
Chocolate/Cocoa
For chocolate pies
Spices (Cinnamon, Nutmeg)
Adds depth and flavor
Note: Some pies may contain dairy or eggs, so be sure to check with the staff if you have dietary restrictions.
Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies: Nutrition Facts
The calorie count for whole pies can vary depending on the flavor and portion size. Here are the estimated nutritional facts for a typical 1/8th serving of each pie:
Tip: The calorie count will vary depending on pie size and extra toppings (whipped cream, ice cream, etc.).
Allergen Information
Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies use ingredients that may contain common allergens. Always notify your server if you have specific dietary concerns.
Allergen
Presence (Possible)
Milk/Dairy
Yes (butter, cream, milk)
Eggs
Yes (in pie filling)
Wheat/Gluten
Yes (in crust and some fillings)
Soy
Possible (in some pie fillings)
Peanuts/Tree Nuts
Yes (in pecan pie)
Fish/Shellfish
Not used
Sesame
Cross-contact possible
Tip: Ask if pies are made with gluten-free crust options or special modifications if needed.
Healthier Tips for Ordering Pies
While whole pies are an indulgent treat, there are ways to enjoy them while being mindful of your health:
Split a pie with friends or family to reduce calorie intake
Order a smaller portion (if available), or request fewer slices of pie
Pair with fresh fruit or a lighter side to balance your meal
Skip the ice cream or extra whipped cream if you’re looking to reduce fat and sugar
Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies vs Other BBQ Pies
Pie Flavor
Calories
Texture
Flavor Profile
Jim N Nick’s Pecan Pie
400–500
Rich & nutty
Sweet, savory, caramelized
Famous Dave’s Pecan Pie
500–600
Creamy & rich
Nutty, sweet, with a buttery filling
Cracker Barrel’s Apple Pie
300–400
Flaky crust, fruity
Tart apples with cinnamon
Sweet Magnolia’s Chocolate Cream Pie
450–600
Creamy, indulgent
Chocolate, velvety, with a whipped top
Jim N Nick’s pies are flakier, less sugary, and made with real ingredients, setting them apart in the BBQ world.
Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies FAQ – 15+ Questions Answered
1. How many calories are in a whole pie?
Each pie generally ranges from 2,000 to 3,500 calories, depending on the flavor.
2. Are the pies made fresh?
Yes, Jim N Nick’s pies are made fresh daily in-house.
3. Can I request a specific pie flavor?
Yes, you can usually request a specific flavor. Some pies may be seasonal.
4. Are the pies available year-round?
No, seasonal pies like sweet potato or strawberry may only be available during certain months.
5. Is there a gluten-free option?
Currently, gluten-free pies are not offered, but you can inquire about pie modifications for dietary needs.
6. Are there any nut-free pies?
The pecan pie contains nuts, but other pies may be nut-free.
7. How much does a whole pie cost?
A whole pie is priced at $17.99.
8. Can I freeze a pie for later?
Yes, most pies freeze well, but pies like cream-based pies should be consumed within a couple of days.
9. Are pies available in smaller portions?
You can often order a slice of pie in-store, but whole pies are typically for larger groups.
10. Does the pie contain artificial ingredients?
No, Jim N Nick’s pies are made from real, high-quality ingredients.
11. Are the pies vegetarian?
Yes, most pies are vegetarian-friendly but not vegan due to dairy and eggs.
12. Can I order a pie online?
Yes, pies can be ordered online via Jim N Nick’s website for pickup or delivery.
13. How long does a whole pie last?
Pies will last 2-3 days in the fridge or up to 3 months in the freezer.
14. Are whipped cream and ice cream included?
Typically, whipped cream is included, but ice cream is not unless requested.
15. Are there any seasonal pies available?
Yes, seasonal pies are often introduced based on availability of fruits and flavors.
Final Summary Table
Feature
Details
Price
$17.99
Calories
400–550 per slice
Vegetarian
Yes
Vegan
No
Gluten-Free
Not offered
Contains Nuts
Yes (pecan pie)
Best Pairings
BBQ, Coffee, Ice Cream
Flavor Profile
Sweet, nutty, fruity, creamy
Customizable?
Can request specific pies or modifications
Final Thoughts
Jim N Nick’s Whole Pies are a perfect example of Southern dessert perfection. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a meal with loved ones, these pies bring that homemade warmth and comfort to the table. Their rich, flaky crusts and fresh, flavorful fillings make them a standout choice in any BBQ spread.
While indulgent, Jim N Nick’s pies remain a staple due to their fresh ingredients and classic Southern charm. They’re sure to make any meal a memorable one.
